A reply to ‘ ‘ Innate phonetic boundaries revisited ’ ’ [ J . Acoust .
نویسنده
چکیده
Before launching into a response to the letter by Aslin, Werker, and Morgan ~2002!, I would like to make clear my belief that the work on infant speech perception has been well executed, and has been critical to the development of general theoretical perspectives on speech perception. I respect and appreciate the contributions of these authors, and consider my own work with children to be a natural extension of their and others’ work on infant speech perception. At the same time, the questions starting to be asked by speech researchers who are not focused solely on infant perception reflect a dramatic change in theoretical perspective, one that is not matched in magnitude by changes in perspective in the infant speech perception work. Many investigators in other areas of speech perception are no longer concerned with trying to identify the acoustic correlates of phonetic categories, or with asking at what age human listeners are able to classify those correlates, or with asking if nonhuman animals can classify those correlates. Nor are other investigators much concerned with distinctions between ‘‘auditory’’ and ‘‘phonetic’’ perception, a recurring theme in the letter of Aslin et al. A general paradigm shift is underway in studies of speech perception toward a focus on how listeners perceptually organize the many properties of the speech signal. For example, Robert Remez and his colleagues ~e.g., Remez et al., 1994! and Robert Shannon and his colleagues ~e.g., Shannon et al., 1995! have convincingly demonstrated that mature listeners can organize signals that are void of the detailed properties that we usually consider acoustic correlates ~or ‘‘cues’’! of phonetic categories in such a way that they still manage to arrive at a phonetically structured message. Investigators studying cross-linguistic speech perception are grappling with fundamental notions of what the objects of speech perception are, and what that means for our understanding of how the perceptual organization of the speech signal is shaped by experiences with a native language ~Strange, 1995!. What we consider to be the initial state of the human capacity for speech perception affects the further development of theories related to these topics, as well as many others. The purpose of the brief article serving as the target of Aslin et al.’s letter was to state explicitly that the evidence is weak to support the position that infants are born able to discriminate all the phonemes of the world’s languages. The authors say it best themselves on page 1259 of their letter, ‘‘Thus, at best, the infant literature supports a weak view of
منابع مشابه
Innate phonetic boundaries revisited (L)
Nittrouer @J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 110, 1598–1605 ~2001!# raised several serious concerns with the so-called Universal Theory of phonetic category development that she characterized as the accepted wisdom in the field of infant speech perception. She then presented data from infants and children that were claimed to be inconsistent with Universal Theory and led her to question the entire notion of ...
متن کاملChallenging the notion of innate phonetic boundaries.
Numerous studies of infants' speech perception abilities have demonstrated that these young listeners have access to acoustic detail in the speech signal. Because these studies have used stimuli that could be described in terms of adult-defined phonetic categories, authors have concluded that infants innately recognize stimuli as members of these categories, as adults do. In fact, the predomina...
متن کاملResolution for speech sounds: Basic sensitivity and context memory on vowel and consonant continua
Discrimination and identification experiments were performed for a vowel continuum (/i//I/-/e/) and two consonant continua (/ba/-/pa/and/ba/-/da/-/ga/). The results were interpreted in terms of a generalization of a theory of intensity resolution [N. I. Durlach and L. D. Braida, J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 46, 372-383 (1969) ] that makes precise the distinction between basic sensitivity (sensory-based ...
متن کاملP-17: Expression of Cell Surface Toll-Like Receptors in the Human Male Reproductive Tract
Background: Male infertility refers to the inability of a male to achieve a pregnancy in a fertile female. The root of many causes of infertility is miscommunication between immune and reproductive system. Male reproductive system is very sensitive and vulnerable, infections can hinder maturation and movement of spermatozoa lead to impaired fertility.All species need an immediate reply to the m...
متن کاملPhonetic alignment constraints: consonant overlap and palatalization in English and Russian
The possibility of di!erences in phonetic alignment of phonological segments was examined by contrasting consonant sequences at word boundaries in Russian and English. In Experiment 1, two acoustic measures of consonant overlap, percent released and duration ratio, are computed for stop sequences at word boundaries, and results for English and Russian are compared. While signi"cant variation du...
متن کامل